The Faithfuls were on a roll this week as they managed to root out two Traitors in a row.
Garda Eamon was the first Traitor to be unmasked and on Tuesday night Katelyn was also found out at another dramatic roundtable.
From the start of the episode, the castle was abuzz with the idea Katelyn was a Traitor.
It seemed like it was going to be a full sweep of the board.
However, viewers were left confused when Mark, Nick and Ben started throwing Andrew’s name around.
Despite this, it was Katelyn who was banished and revealed that she was a Traitor.
It was meant to be a moment of delight, however, Nick and Ben shared their annoyance that they banished Katelyn as everyone “knew” she was a Traitor. They even went on to say that she could have been “kept under their thumb” and be “controlled”.
Viewers were left fairly confused by this statement.
“Katelyn’s a traitor
“yeah, definitely”
“Will we vote her out tonight?”
“No, let’s vote out Andrew”
Make it make sense#TraitorsIRL pic.twitter.com/wy9yhb51Pv
— Jack Squibb (@jacksquibb) September 9, 2025
The faithfuls should only be worrying about the traitors not having to watch their backs at the other faithfuls being out to get them too, those 3 are not team players in any sense of the word. #TraitorsIreland #TraitorsIRL
— Surviving2025 (@Survivinthe20s) September 9, 2025
Stuck on how weird it is that Nick & Ben felt they could influence Katelyn as a Traitor. They were toddler-on-a-supermarket-floor levels of big mad with everyone for voting her out. With the focus having been on Eamon, we may have missed the wannabe Machiavellis #TraitorsIRL
— Aoife (@SiogMara) September 9, 2025
Nick & Ben’s agenda leaked #TraitorsIRL #TraitorsIreland pic.twitter.com/MWnmiNLf7V
— ⋆˙⟡ Hannah °❀.ೃ࿔* (@wasabibestie) September 9, 2025
Okay now I’ve turned on Ben and Nick. Their plan made them just as bad as the traitors, killing off faithful one by one so they’d make it to the end. Traitors by proxy.
Little misogynistic too, three lads claiming they “could have played” and “controlled” her. #TraitorsIRL
— Paul B (@PaulBonass) September 9, 2025
Mark, Nick and Ben got cocky after they were named the funniest, the leader and the best at missions at the casino, that’s when they thought they were untouchable and would not be banished. Absolute bellends. #TraitorsIreland #TraitorsIRL
— Surviving2025 (@Survivinthe20s) September 9, 2025
Nick and Ben hatching this random master plan to “control” Katelyn #TraitorsIRL pic.twitter.com/f2SLno3DAh
— Nessa (@nessadinneen) September 9, 2025
Nick and Ben thinking they’re masterminds by revealing their secret plan and making themselves targets from both sides #TraitorsIRL pic.twitter.com/xUq6QPWBKk
— Rich Pete (@O5Rich) September 9, 2025
Mark, Nick and Ben were getting rid of a rival when they tried to get Andrew, they have a little pact going to get rid of strong opposition to them. #TraitorsIRL #TraitorsIreland
— Surviving2025 (@Survivinthe20s) September 9, 2025
Ultimately the episode ended with Paudie trying to recruit his son Andrew as a Traitor. But we’ll have to wait until Sunday night to find out…
